$9.96
$42.61
bear $9.96
base $25.08
bull $42.61
margin of safety $14.00
market price* $37.44
Business condition attached to the margin of safety
The pending all-cash acquisition of LiveRamp by Publicis Groupe at $38.50 per share is terminated or abandoned and the company remains independent and publicly traded.
LiveRamp sells data-connectivity and identity software that lets advertisers, publishers and other companies match and share customer data safely across systems. Subscriptions were $614 million of fiscal 2026 revenue ($813 million, year ended March 31, 2026); the rest is usage-based marketplace and related services. There is no financial debt and about $371 million of cash and short-term investments at June 30, 2026 (we count about $331 million of it as surplus, or $5.35 per share, keeping roughly $40 million for operations). Operating-lease obligations of about $33 million are ordinary rent already paid out of operating cash flow and are not treated as debt. Pending transaction. On May 16, 2026 LiveRamp agreed to be acquired by Publicis Groupe for $38.50 per share in cash, expected to close by the end of calendar 2026 subject to shareholder, antitrust, foreign-investment and CFIUS approvals. Everything below values LiveRamp as a stand-alone business and does not assume the deal closes. How we measure earnings. Owner earnings are operating cash flow, minus the swing in working capital, minus stock-based compensation (a real cost paid in shares), minus the capital spending needed to stay in business (tiny here: $1.4 million). Fiscal 2026 came to $104 million ($1.60 per share on 65.0 million diluted shares), versus $14 million in fiscal 2025 and $26 million in fiscal 2024; the series for fiscal 2020 to 2023 is negative (roughly -$0.60 to -$1.45 per share). Fiscal 2025 looks weak partly because we strip out a $31 million working-capital inflow, and fiscal 2026 looks stronger because we add back a $20 million outflow (mostly a $28 million receivables build that management attributes to revenue growth and collection timing; Q1 of fiscal 2027 saw only a $4 million build). We also remove two items that flatter the headline: the $56 million non-cash tax benefit booked in fiscal 2026 when valuation allowances were released, and about $15 million of interest income on the cash pile, which we count separately as cash instead of capitalizing it a second time. That leaves roughly $89 million of operating cash flow, about $1.44 per share on today's 61.8 million diluted shares. Amortization of acquired intangibles is only about $11 million a year, so wasting acquired assets are not a material issue. Level chosen. We anchor on fiscal 2026 rather than a multi-year median, because the business changed in that year: operating income rose from $5 million to $83 million while revenue grew 9%, as operating expenses fell $33 million (stock compensation from $108 million to $83 million, R&D from $177 million to $148 million). Earlier years describe a company with a much heavier cost base. We are not relying on one print: the last three quarters of fiscal 2026 ran at about a 12% operating margin and the June 2026 quarter reached $20.2 million operating income against $7.2 million a year earlier, with stock compensation of $20.9 million against $25.4 million. A median of fiscal 2024 to 2026 would be only $0.38 per share; if the true level turned out to be half of fiscal 2026, the shares would be worth about $14.60. We also deduct $7.5 million a year of extra cash taxes from year one: cash taxes paid were only $2.1 million in fiscal 2026 against a current tax provision of $9.6 million, and federal loss carryforwards are small ($19 million), so the shield is not long-lived. Growth reconciliation. The actual fiscal 2026 growth in owner earnings (about $14 million to $104 million) is far above the 5% we assume for year one in the base case, so no deceleration needs explaining; the assumption is deliberately kept at the low end of revenue growth of 10.6%, 13.0% and 9.0% over the last three years. Base case: about $25 per share. The business is worth about $1,220 million ($19.73 per share), the company owes nothing, and surplus cash adds $5.35. Cash flow grows 5%, 5%, 4%, 4%, 3%, 3%, 3%, 2%, 2%, 2% from $86 million in year one to $116 million in year ten, then holds level through year twenty and is worth nothing after that. What puts that growth in the bag: $760 million of contracted future revenue (of which $518 million lands in the next twelve months, running to 2032), annualized recurring revenue up 8%, subscription net retention of 107% (104% a year earlier), and revenue growth that continued through the 2022-23 advertising slowdown. What is left out: any further margin expansion, new products such as the data-collaboration tools, share gains, and the effect of share buybacks. The flat years eleven to twenty rest on net retention above 100%, meaning the installed base has not been shrinking; nothing evidenced extends that beyond year twenty. Bear case: about $10 per share. The business is worth about $285 million ($4.61 per share), there is no debt, and surplus cash adds $5.35. The story: year one is protected by contracted revenue; in years two and three an advertising downturn like 2022-23 (when the company swung to a $126 million operating loss, restructuring included) combines with the loss of some of its ten largest customers, who make up about 30% of revenue, to take revenue down 8% a year to about $688 million (-15%). Costs are sticky, so 40 cents of every lost revenue dollar comes out of cash flow: $89 million falls to $39 million, and cash taxes rising toward a normal 25% of pretax profit (a $22 million drag) take it to a trough of about $17 million. Revenue then grows 2 to 3% a year with only 20 cents of each added dollar reaching cash flow, reaching $36 million in year ten, and fades to zero by year fifteen because nothing in the filings shows the franchise defending itself against the large closed advertising platforms and privacy rule changes beyond that. Even this case carries its own cost base with no borrowing needed. Because this business did not exist in its present form in 2008-09, we used its own 2022-23 experience as the downturn episode. Bull case: about $43 per share. The business is worth about $2,305 million ($37.26 per share), no debt, plus $5.35 of surplus cash. Revenue grows 9%, 9%, 8%, 8%, 7%, 6%, 5%, 4%, 3%, 3% to about $1.48 billion, within what the company has delivered in each of the last three years, and a quarter of each added revenue dollar reaches cash flow (fiscal 2026 showed operating costs falling while revenue rose). Cash flow reaches about $249 million in year ten and stays there through year twenty. What would make this wrong. Fiscal 2026 is the first year at the current cost level; if competitors or the large advertising platforms squeeze data-connectivity pricing, or if stock compensation climbs back toward fiscal 2025's $108 million (about a $0.40 per share swing), the base case is too high. We tested the cost reduction against the June 2026 quarter, tested whether the $15 million of interest income and the $28 million receivables build were hiding anything, and found the results held. We could not reconcile why fiscal 2025 operating income was so low against fiscal 2026 from the filings beyond the stock-compensation and headcount reductions stated above. Previous estimates were prepared on a different basis and are not comparable; what has changed in the business since then is the June 2026 quarter (revenue up 10% to $214 million, operating income nearly tripled, share count down to 61.8 million) and that the pending Publicis transaction is still awaiting its approvals. Margin-of-safety price: $14.00. We are moderately, not highly, sure of the earnings level: one full year plus one quarter at the new cost base, backed by contracts but with ten customers making up 30% of revenue and a record in which owner earnings were negative in four of the last seven years. The worst plausible outcome, a downturn plus customer losses, would cut cash flow to roughly $17 million, but with no debt and about $5.35 per share of surplus cash the company would survive it comfortably, and the shares would still be worth about $10. If we are wrong about the earnings level (half of fiscal 2026 gives about $14.60; a third gives about $11) or about stock compensation staying near $83 million, the shares are worth roughly the margin-of-safety price. The price assumes a holding period of three to five years; the company pays no dividend, but it uses cash to retire shares ($17.6 million in the June 2026 quarter) and keeps building cash. At $14.00 the price is about $8.65 per share net of surplus cash for a business producing about $1.40 per share of cash flow after stock compensation and extra taxes, roughly a 16% yield before any growth, so a few percent of the growth we consider already in the bag implies a 20% annual return even if the multiple never changes. The price applies only if the Publicis transaction ends without closing, because while it is pending the share price reflects the transaction, not the business.